Breaking Points: On Afghanistan, the Revolving Door, & Media Failure to Disclose Contracting Ties of Guests
Discussing the forever war & the prospects for a third party with old friends Krystal Ball & Saagar Enjeti.
Krystal Ball & Saagar Enjeti’s Breaking Points is a lot like what TV news would look like if the top dozen or so noxious propaganda imperatives were removed from the broadcast equation. They do a great job of focusing on underlying issues ignored by the usual suspects.
In an interview yesterday about a piece Matt Taibbi wrote on Afghanistan, Krystal & Saagar brought up questions Matt overlooked, including the revolving door in the contracting world, as well as the remarkable intransigence of the corporate press on the “forever war” front. Many long-ago disgraced or discredited hawks were mysteriously revived to play analyst as the gruesome footage from Kabul rolled in. “The same liars are elevated despite the fact that we knew they were lying,” noted Saagar.
TV rehabilitation of the idiots who got America into the Afghan mess was so conspicuous that it became a late-night punchline, with even Seth Myers making a bit about it. Myers only focused on the Republican ghouls revived, but he at least noticed, while Vox did a more comprehensive review that also puzzled over the on-air presence of people like Leon Panetta, who oversaw Barack Obama’s “surge.”
Krystal meanwhile brought up the problem of the revolving door. “After you finish your ‘public service,’ a lot of these people go & work in the defense industry, or they go & sit on a board,” she said.
This is not only true, it’s a significant related problem to the first issue of pro-war officials herded on air to argue for extended deployments. In a lot of the recent coverage of Afghanistan, we’ve seen Big Five contractor board members not identified as such. Here’s how the author bio originally read ~ hat tip Wayback Machine ~ for an April 16th Washington Post op-ed by Meghan O’Sullivan & Richard Haass called, “It’s wrong to pull troops out of Afghanistan. But we can minimize the damage”:
Here’s how that bio reads today, after the Post caught some flak for failing to disclose a key detail.
Here’s how the New York Times described O’Sullivan in an August 28th piece by Peter Baker, arguing for a “Middle Ground” strategy instead of a full pullout. Note Waldo is missing here, too:
You can find endless examples of this, as chronicled recently by the likes of David Sirota, Lee Fang, Rosa Adams, & Ryan Grim, as well as by Adam Johnson. All these reporters have done a great job of pointing out that we’re almost told about the affiliations of TV guest pundits like David Petraeus (on the board at KKR), former Defense Secretary Mark Esper (a Raytheon alum), General Jack Keane (Humvee maker AM General), Condoleezza Rice (Pentagon contractor C3.ai) & many, many others.
A typical “silent contractor” media tour looks like the recent one involving “former DHS Secretary” Jeh Johnson, who has been opining a lot on the grimness of the Afghan situation of late — “My concern is that it could get worse before it gets better” was a much-circulated observation. Not one of the cable outlets hosting him bothered to note that he sits on the board of Lockheed-Martin. CNN didn’t:
"My concern is that it could get worse before it gets better," says former Secretary of Homeland Security Jeh Johnson of the security situation in Afghanistan.
— The Situation Room (@CNNSitRoom) August 20, 2021
"We may not have seen yet the worst of this crisis," he warns. pic.twitter.com/bz8kHgxKJj
Nor did CBS’s Face the Nation:
Former DHS Sec. Jeh Johnson on Afghanistan: “If I were advising the president, I probably would have recommended that we keep in place, in country, a highly-trained force of about 2500 or so for counterterrorism purposes. The president, I know, understands the stakes.” pic.twitter.com/tR7fMCqGA7
— Face The Nation (@FaceTheNation) July 11, 2021
Nor did CBS This Morning:
Obama DHS Secretary Jeh Johnson: Afghanistan government collapsed “rapidly because of the way in which we got out” pic.twitter.com/Wom6mjqrQp
— RNC Research (@RNCResearch) August 17, 2021
Nor did did MSNBC:
& so on & so on.
A lot of people want to look at the bright side with this withdrawal, & they should, up to a point. However much he may have botched the planning, Joe Biden deserves credit for sticking to his timeline. It is good news that the United States can eventually recognize that a war has stopped serving any purpose, & actually decide to leave a country ten years after the last theoretical reason for staying has expired.
However, the fact that both the government & the national commentariat remain essentially captured by contractor money remains as big a problem as ever, as this episode shows. We haven’t even reached the stage of being able to identify the financial connections of the people occupying center stage on the national televised debate over military policy. It’s a terrible look that the people willing to point things like this out mostly all work for independent media outlets, while the New York Times & Washington Post have to be harassed to do the ethical minimum on that score.
If we properly identified the sponsors of the people with the biggest voices in media & politics, a lot more of what America does at home & around the world would make sense. We need more of that, & thanks to Krystal & Saagar for bringing the topic up.
“Within me was an insistence that whatever we did, the things that were said, the dawns, the cities, the lives, all of it had to be drawn together, made into pages, or it was in danger of not existing, of never having been. There comes a time when you realize that everything is a dream, & only those things preserved in writing have any possibility of being real." ~ Curated Excerpt From: Timothy Denevi. “Freak Kingdom.” Apple Books.
Curated via Matt Taibbi. Thanks for reading, cheers! (with a glass of wine & book of course)
2016 Capanne Ricci Brunello Di Montalcino
Producer: Tenimenti Capanne Ricci, Brunello di Montalcino, Tuscany, Italy
"Underbrush, leather & red-skinned-berry aromas emerge from the glass. The juicy, balanced palate delivers cherry, crushed raspberry & tobacco alongside fine-grained tannins & bright acidity. Drink 2023–2035." ~ 94 Points ~ Wine Enthusiast
Freak Kingdom: Hunter S. Thompson’s Manic Ten-Year Crusade Against American Fascism
The story of Hunter S. Thompson's crusade against Richard Nixon and the threat of fascism in America ~ and the devastating price he paid for it.
Hunter S. Thompson is often misremembered as a wise-cracking, drug-addled cartoon character. This book reclaims him for what he truly was: a fearless opponent of corruption and fascism, one who sacrificed his future well-being to fight against it, rewriting the rules of journalism and political satire in the process. This skillfully told and dramatic story shows how Thompson saw the danger of Richard Nixon early and embarked on a life-defining campaign to stop it. In his fevered effort to expose institutional injustice, Thompson pushed himself far beyond his natural limits, sustained by drugs, mania, and little else. For ten years, he cast aside his old ambitions, troubled his family, and likely hastened his own decline, along the way producing some of the best political writing in our history.
This timely biography recalls a period of anger and derangement in American politics, and one writer with the guts to tell the truth.
